Best Crib Mattress

Crib mattresses are very different from classic mattresses as we know them, not only in terms of size and shape but also in terms of features and specifications. These mattresses tend to be smaller and specifically designed to meet the needs of a small child – they are waterproof and made from high-quality, safe materials that do not pose any risk for suffocation. Here are the top 5 best crib mattresses on the market:

1. The Safety 1st Heavenly Dreams Crib Mattress

Safety 1st is known as a premier American company that developed an exclusive line of child-safe products, from strollers and mattresses to nursery monitors and car seats. Manufactured by Safety 1st, this is a white crib mattress – waterproof, firm enough to support the child yet soft enough to ensure a comfortable and uninterrupted sleep, the mattress is very lightweight.

The mattress also features a vinyl-based sleeping surface that is free of heavy metals such as lead or mercury, and it contains no phthalates whatsoever. All the materials used for making the Safety 1st Heavenly Dreams crib mattress are hypoallergenic and specifically designed for very sensitive toddlers.

Features And Specifications

The mattress also features a sturdy cover that is very durable and highly resistant to odors and stains, and it is designed to fit all the standard cribs. The interior of the mattress features a fiber core for the best and most durable support possible, it is flame retardant and it does not contain any chemicals that may endanger the life and health of the child.

When it comes to the Heavenly Dreams White Crib mattress, safety is the first and most important aspect. Safety 1st is known to placing the safety of the toddler before anything else, the mattress features no springs or coils at all and the cover is designed to completely zip off for cleaning and drying whenever needed.

The mattresses made and sold by Safety 1st are very durable and child-friendly, they are cost-effective and this one measures 52 inches in length, 27.5 inches in width and approximately 6 inches in thickness. With a very light weight of only 7 pounds, this mattress is perfect for standard toddler beds and cribs.

One of the aspects that make this mattress so durable and reliable is the thermo bonded core which is very body conforming and versatile. Light and flexible at the same time, the mattress allows the baby to move freely, and the parents can change the sheets quickly and without the hassles. The mattress does not retain moisture or odors, and it can be used for years without losing its shape or elasticity.

This mattress by Safety 1st is organic, which means that it features only materials that are derived from living matter and that have a very low risk for triggering allergies. Carefully designed with the toddler in mind, the mattress offers an unparalleled body support for the health and correct development of the child, it is 100% safe to use and it will not cave or hollow after years of use.

Pros And Cons

One of the main benefits of this mattress is the fact that it comes with a tear resistant cover that resists odors and stains, and the high density thermo bonded fiber core is designed for a firm and durable support. The mattress has a hypoallergenic sleeping surface and it meets all the Federal flammability standards.

However, this mattress does have some downsides as well – as many parents claim, the mattress can sometimes become uneven and it can slowly bend, thus causing the toddler to roll. In spite of its child-oriented and sturdy construction, the mattress has no baby side whatsoever and sometimes it can be too soft for a growing toddler.

Regardless of all these aspects, the Safety 1st Heavenly Dreams mattress does offer a great price per quality ratio and it is a very popular choice these days.

2. The Keep Me Dry Waterproof Crib Mattress By Carter’s

This mattress by Carter’s is specifically designed for small babies who regularly wet their beds, and who need a high-quality, waterproof mattress to keep them dry when that happens. One of the most daunting tasks as a parent is to wake up in the middle of the night and change the child when these small nocturnal accidents happen, due to the fact that bed wetting triggers the toddler’s restlessness during bed time.

Features And Specifications

Fortunately, the Keep Me Dry Waterproof quilted crib pad is the best choice for parents who want to offer both their toddler and themselves a good and restful night’s sleep. Smooth and very soft to the touch, the mattress can be easily fitted into a standard size baby bed or crib, and it also provides the little one with great comfort and support, which in turn reduces the tossing and turning during the night.

This pad is designed to fit most of the baby crib mattresses regardless of the brand that manufactures them, it is slightly flexible and durable and it also offers a very snug fit. Besides this, the pad stands out from the rest through its soft and luxurious feel that is given by its exquisite quilt design – the mattress is only made of materials of the highest quality such as 100% polyester, which offers the ultimate protection against common bed wetting accidents.

As a matter of fact, it is the waterproof property of this mattress that makes it so sought-after, as diaper leaks are anything but uncommon, and they can be a nuisance at times. Fortunately, the 100% waterproof pad is designed not to retain the moisture while still enhancing the overall comfort of your child at the same time.

The secret lies in the unique combination of polyester and vinyl filling that makes the pad highly resistant to both spills and moisture, thus keeping the mattress and the crib clean, dry and sanitized.

This mattress pad features 52 inches in length and 28 inches in width, which is the standard size for a crib mattress and it can be used both for toddler and for crib mattresses alike. Moreover, it comes with reinforced corners that will allow you to easily attach it to the sides of the mattress, without worrying that it may roll during the night.

The Pros And Cons Of The Carter’s Keep Me Dry Waterproof Crib Mattress

The main benefit of this pad is that not only is it highly efficient for keeping moisture and spills at bay, but it has a plush surface that makes it very soft and comfortable. This pad has all the main properties and features any great crib mattress pad should have, and it can also be washed and dried quickly and without the hassles.

On the other hand, some parents claim that the mattress pad has shrunk a bit after it was washed in the washing machine several time, this is why it is highly recommended to hand wash and air dry the pad, in order to prolong its average lifespan and to maintain its properties and quality. If you do this, this crib mattress pad will be as good as new for months to come!

3. The Sealy Soybean Foam-Core Mattress

This is yet another organic crib mattress, manufactured and sold by Sealy. With an ultra firm level of comfort, the mattress guarantees durability and air freshness in the long run, as it has been tested for chemical content and it does not interfere with the indoor air quality in any way, thus creating a safe and sound sleeping environment for the toddlers.

Features And Specifications

Sealy is one of the leading manufacturers of sleep products in the industry, and its wide array of crib mattresses and toddler mattresses certainly testify to that. The Sealy baby brand has been in the business for more than 100 years, and it has always managed to rise to the expectations of its customers by providing baby products of an irreproachable quality.

This mattress has risen to all the crib mattress standards set by ASTM, it is certified for a healthy indoor environment and it has a very sturdy design that adds to its comfort and lifespan. The mattress is also designed to stay in place throughout the entire night, without unravelling when the child tosses and turns.

Ventilation is one of the most important aspects to consider when choosing a crib mattress, and the Soybeam foam-core crib mattress by Sealy has a great ventilation system. In a nutshell, it features an airflow pocket that is specifically designed to support natural and side effect-free ventilation, without using any metal vents unlike other mattresses.

The mattresses features an exquisite and advanced sleep technology and it also comes with a generous lifetime warranty on the materials and the craftsmanship, thus allowing you to return it to the manufacturer as quickly as you notice any problems related to the production process.

It is a known fact that small children require a different level of comfort – they must have a firm crib mattress that supports the correct bone growth and development, one that is firm and flat enough for them to get the support and cushioning they so much need. The Sealy Soybeam-foam core mattress provides your toddler with just that – the high density core of the mattress helps the little one sleep throughout the entire night, without waking you up.

The soybean-foam core is organic and natural, given the fact that it represents a renewable source that has been tested and carefully picked. Moreover, the high-density foam featured within the mattress is CertiPUR-US certified, meaning that it will offer the same premium level of comfort for you baby and it has absolutely no dangerous chemicals or heavy metals in it.

An important benefit of this mattress is that it can be cleaned and dried within minutes, due to its pearl embossed cover that is waterproof and that can be easily cleaned with a piece of damp cloth or baby wipes. The waterproof surface will prevent liquids from entering the mattress and leading to mold and mildew, and it will also keep the baby safe and dry even after the common night time accidents.

The mattress has been carefully tested to make sure that it matches the standard crib size, it is made entirely in the United States of America and it measures 52 inches in length, 28 inches in width and 5 inches in thickness.

This is an award winning product that was voted the best mattress for babies I America, it has a practical square corner design and it has also received the much appreciated GreenGuard Gold Certification, which means that is ensures a healthier indoor environment.

The mattress comes with a lifetime warranty on both the materials and the workmanship, and it is suitable for both newborns and children between the ages of 0 and four that weigh up to 60 pounds. This Sealy baby crib mattress relies on some of the best and most child-friendly natural materials for the best level of comfort the little one can get.

The mattress is very firm yet incredibly lightweight at the same time, as it is known that the soybeam-based foam is light and highly efficient, not to mention that it is also very friendly with the surrounding environment.

In addition to this, the surface of the mattress is also highly resistant to spills and stains, it is very easy to clean and it ensures a safe and sanitary environment for the baby to sleep during the entire night. The mattress is flame retardant and it has managed to pass all the flammability tests it has been subjected to.

4. The Moonlight Slumber Dual Firmness Crib Mattress

Manufactured by Moonlight Slumber, the Little Dreamer dual firmness crib mattress is entirely made of foam of superior quality. Even though this is slightly more expensive than the other mattresses reviewed above, it undoubtedly offers a great value for the money and it is also one of the highest rated crib mattresses in its niche.

Features And Specifications

Designed as one of the safest and most comfortable baby and crib mattresses on the market, this product comes with a dual sided sleeping surface, it has a firm level of comfort and it will support the proper growth and development of your child during the first few years of life.

The mattress is made of extra firm, high density foam and it matches all the safety and comfort standards that apply, from dropped edge seams and a natural internal fire barrier to a high quality medical grade foam used for the interior of the mattress.

The mattress features simple yet toddler-friendly clean lines, it has a smooth surface that is very pleasant to the touch and it also measures 5 inches in thickness, which ensures its durability in the long run. The mattress is free of lead or heavy metals, it contains no phthalates whatsoever and it is also free of vinyl, PVC and polyethylene. The mattress comes with a long-lasting nylon cover and it is also waterproof.

The foam used for the interior of the mattress is entirely natural and it has received the CertiPUR-US certification, it has side stitched seams and it is also hypoallergenic, thus being the most suitable choice for very sensitive children.

The mattress offers an outstanding antibacterial and antimicrobial protection, it is very easy to clean and just like the mattresses reviewed above, it also comes with a lifetime warranty that allows you to have the mattress changed, repaired or refunded if you notice any manufacturer defects.

Designed both for infants and toddlers, the mattress offers unmatched comfort and quality, it weight only 8 pounds and it has a very elegant appearance. Regarding the specifications of the product, it measures 52 inches in length and 27.5 inches in width, which is the standard crib size. Unlike other products of this kind, the Little Dreamer mattress by Moonlight Slumber does not contain any springs or coils.

The mattress is made in the United States of America and it is made of environmentally friendly materials of the highest quality – no low grade compounds or chemicals were involved in the manufacturing of this mattress. The mattress is flame retardant and it also has an almost invisible side stitching that helps the mattress retain its flatness and overall shape and design over the years.

The mattress is completely waterproofed and it contains no crevices or small entry spaces whatsoever, therefore it is not susceptible to mold or mildew even when the little one has an accident, which is very common for toddlers especially during the night.

A Closer Look At The Main Benefits

This mattress has a series of notable benefits, and the dual sided densities (firm vs. extra form) makes it suitable both for toddlers and for infants. Hypoallergenic and natural, the mattress does not have any dangerous gaps, it is easy to clean, it is lightweight and it allows quick and effortless sheet changes.

The baby will enjoy the best comfort while sleeping on the mattress and will not sink into it, and the mattress does not give any unpleasant foul odor when unpacked. Moreover, it is specifically designed not to retain the heat and to keep the baby cool and comfortable even when the temperatures rise.

5. The My First Mattress Memory Foam Crib mattress

Made and sold by My First Mattress, this baby product comes with a waterproof cover that is specifically designed to ensure a restful and safe night’s sleep for the little one. That being said, the mattress features extra firm, very dense foam that offers the best support a child can get, and it measures 52 inches in length, 27.5 inches in width and 5 inches in thickness.

With square corners, the mattress allows you to easily change the sheets and it will keep them in place throughout the whole night, preventing them from rolling and disturbing the baby.

The mattress meets all the safety standards set for crib mattresses, and it fully meets both the CPSC standards and the standards set for Federal Flammability. Free of phthalates, lead, mercury or other dangerous heavy metals, the My First Mattress memory foam crib mattress is hypoallergenic, it has antibacterial and antimicrobial properties and it is also designed to keep the dust mites at bay.

The cover of the mattress is 100% washable and waterproof, it comes with a removable plush velour cover and it is also designed to keep moisture away, thus preventing the growth of bacteria, mold or mildew that may trigger severe respiratory conditions for the toddler. The mattress comes with a 10 year manufacturer warranty, it is very comfortable yet extra firm at the same time.

In addition to this, the mattress also comes with handy and practical square cut corners that ensure a snug fit, and it also comes with a useful and soft velour cover that is made 100% from polyester. The cover can be entirely removed and washed without any effort. The firm sleeping surface makes sure that the baby is growing healthy bones and muscles, and it is also designed to reduce the amount of tossing and turning that is not uncommon for toddlers, during the night.

How To Choose The Best Crib Mattress For Your Infant?

There are several aspects one must keep in mind when buying a good mattress for their baby. Comfort is undoubtedly a very important factor that must be taken into account, but health comes first. With that in mind, it is important to opt for a mattress that is hypoallergenic, that does not pollute the indoor air and that also supports the correct growth of the bones. It is also important to opt for a mattress that is specifically designed for babies, as this means that the mattress has met all the standards set in the industry.

The firmness of the mattress is strongly related to the health of the infant, as a soft sleeping surface dramatically increases the risk for SIDS. This is why it is of utmost importance never to use an adults’ mattress for a baby, as it may be too soft for the little one’s needs. Other than that, the durability or the price per quality ratio are two other aspect that must be taken into account, and you must remember that the crib mattress should be durable enough to last for at least three years. Here is a brief overview of some of the aspects to consider:

1. Snug Fit

Professionals and manufacturers cannot stress enough the importance of choosing a crib mattress that comes with a very snug fit. It is essential to take the exact measurements of the baby crib (although they usually come in a standard size) and to make sure that the space between the side of the mattress and the crib fame does not exceed two fingers.

If the distance is larger than that, then the child can fall and stay entrapped there, which may lead to suffocation. The ideal crib mattress for babies should measure 52 inches in length, 27.5 inches in width and approximately 5 inches in height.

2. Become Familiar With The Different Types Of Crib Mattresses

Just like the regular mattresses for adults, the crib mattresses also come in many different types. The two most common types are foam and innerspring, and foam mattresses tend to be more popular and safer at the same time. A foam crib mattress is cost-effective and lightweight, it does not exceed 6 inches in thickness, it has a high density of around 1.5 pounds and they also offer a great level of support and firmness.

Nonetheless, before buying a foam crib mattress for your child make sure to always check the packaging and the instructions, to make sure the dimensions and size matches those of the crib, and that the foam mattress is dense enough. On average, a good foam crib mattress should weigh around 7 pounds, and it is highly recommended to opt for the lightest ones you can find, otherwise changing the sheets in the middle of the night can be a very difficult task.

On the other hand, many people argue the safety of innerspring mattresses, which are not only more expensive but also less comfortable than the foam mattresses, in general. Nonetheless, these mattresses tend to be a better long-term investment, given the fact that they last two to three times more than their foam-based counterparts.

If you have decided to opt for an innerspring crib mattress, make sure to pay attention to the number of coils, the firmness rating, the wire gauge and the number of turns per coil. All these factors are extremely important for the health, the safety and the comfort of the little one.

3. Pay Attention To The Resiliency Of The Mattress

Although crib mattresses cannot be tested the same way as adult mattresses, you can certainly inspect their resiliency rating before buying them – simply push against the mattress and see if and how quickly it comes back to its initial shape.

A good memory foam-based mattress should retain its shape and instantly come back to its initial form, but if it does not, then your child may have a difficult time sleeping at night, especially if he turns and tosses a lot.

4. Consider Organic Baby Mattresses

Most, if not all specialists agree on the fact that organic or all-natural crib mattresses are better alternatives to the classic ones. These products are usually made from cotton or wool (both of which are known to act as efficient fire barriers), they are lightweight, they do not contain any dangerous chemicals, compounds or heavy metals neither do they affect the quality of the indoor air. Besides, organic mattresses are available both in the innerspring and in memory foam-based version.

Do not let yourself tricked by the slightly more expensive price tag that the organic crib mattresses usually have, as they truly do offer the best quality for the money. Not only do these mattresses offer you the peace of mind any caring parent wants, but they also contain no PBDEs, neither do they emit any toxic gases or substances that can get into the body of the babies. Besides, some of the synthetic materials can trigger severe allergic reactions in infants.

Your baby’s safety comes first, and if you are concerned about that, then it is highly recommended to do your research and to opt for the crib mattress that comes with the lowest level of toxicity. Ideally, opt for a mattress that comes with a CertiPUR-US certification, or any other green-rated certification that guarantees its organic nature.

5. Do Not Ignore The Ventilation System

It is a known fact that toddlers tend to wet their beds at night, and while choosing a mattress that is either waterproof or comes with a waterproof cover/pad is crucial, it is also important to make sure it has enough venting. Most crib mattresses these days come with very small vent holes located on the sides of the mattress that ensure a continuous and uninterrupted air flow. The more holes there are, the better.

Generally speaking, most high-quality and expensive mattresses made by reputable brands have a great ventilation system that allow your baby’s skin to breath and that also keep the unpleasant odors at bay. It is important to know that the vent holes also vary in terms of number and size – some of them are small and have a round shape, while other vents tend to be larger. Each type has its own advantages and disadvantages.

6. Look For A High Quality Mattress Cover

The thumb rule that applies both to adult mattresses and to baby crib mattresses is that the quality, the composition and the features of the cover or pad are at least as important as those of the mattress itself. That being said, most of the time the crib mattress covers are slightly quilted and they are made of vinyl. Sometimes, they only have one layer while other times they can have two or more layers – the more layers there are to the cover, the more protection it offers.

Both nylon and vinyl covers are good as long as they are thick and reinforced with materials that will increase their durability and lifespan without making any compromise in terms of comfort and performance. Affordable and useful, the covers can add extra protection to the mattress, they are usually waterproof and they also contribute to a restful and relaxing night’s sleep.

If you get to choose, it is highly recommended to opt for multi-layered crib mattress covers, as each layer has its own properties and benefits. These covers tend to be antimicrobial and anti-mite, they are antibacterial and they also prevent any germ or bacterial growth that can occur due to diaper accidents.

7. Pay Attention To The Cost

Crib mattresses tend to be a lot more affordable than the regular adult mattresses, and you can get a very good and durable mattress for you baby with just under $100, if you know where to look for. This aspect is particularly important for those who are on a budget, as you do not need to sacrifice the safety, usefulness, practicability or durability of the mattress to save some money.

However, if you aim for a crib mattress made by a world-renowned brand, then the chances are that it will be several tens of dollars more expensive than a mattress from a less famous name, even though it may have the exact same features and specifications.

Generally speaking, mattresses that are made of natural or organic materials and those that come with special covers designed to add to support the hypoallergenic or waterproof features of the mattress tend to be more expensive.

8. Quality Over Quantity

Quality comes at a price, but when it comes to the safety of your child, it is important to get the highest quality mattress you can get your hands on. Memory foam mattresses are high-quality and affordable, yet you should expect an average lifespan of three to four years before you need to have them replaced.

The innerspring mattresses come with vinyl coverings that are prone to cracking or tearing in the long run, and although they tend to be more expensive, they also tend to be reinforced, thicker and puncture resistant.

9. Make Sure The Size Of The Mattress Matches That Of The Crib

This may sound as a simple and obvious thing to do, but most parents go shopping for a crib mattress without actually taking the measurements of the crib first, assuming that it has a standard size. In addition to the size, it is also important to pay attention to the fir of the mattress, as it must fit relatively tight inside the crib.

Also, pay attention to the return policy of the store, just in case you have purchased a mattress that does not rise to your expectations or that does not have a snug fit inside the bed.

10. Certified Crib Mattresses Are The Best!

The ultimate guarantee that your money is well-spent is a certification provided by the American Society for Testing and Materials or by the CPSC, as this certification shows that the product has been thoroughly tested and found to be compliant with all the safety standards that are met.

The review bodies responsible for certifying organic materials usually review the mattress based on the organic textile standards that apply worldwide.

The Bottom Line

To conclude, the price of the crib mattress does not guarantee its quality or performance – although expensive mattresses tend to be more safer, more durable and more efficient, this is not a generally applicable rule. Always read the label of the mattress and pay attention to the specifications before making your choice!

Contact Us

We're not around right now. But you can send us an email and we'll get back to you, asap.

Start typing and press Enter to search